A year after his father’s death, Jay (Austin Abrams), returns home to his seaside California town for a memorial to Mitt (Josh Brolin), a whale tour captain and something of a local legend; a sentiment not particularly held by his son. Conflicted, he goes to the beach early the morning after the memorial, suits up in his diving gear, and goes out under the water to feel close to his tough-love father who died at sea. While on the edge of the shelf, Jay gets caught in a tussle between a giant squid and a sperm whale. The squid, reaching out for anything it can, gets a grip on Jay, just in time for the whale to capture the squid in its jaws, swallowing them both.
Brian Duffield directs Whalefall from a script he cowrote with Daniel Kraus, adapting his own 2023 novel of the same name for 20th Century Studios. The film was teased at CinemaCon in the spring, clearing the way for a summer of buzz around the next major maritime disaster film placed peculiarly in late October instead of the dog days of summer when these titles tend to take off. Running 106 minutes, the film boasts plenty of pulse pounding sequences, but it goes beyond that and evolves into a film with a surprising amount of heart given the beach read premise.
The film opens with Mitt on a boat, just off the Monastery Beach, while Hewey (John Ortiz), with his back to the shuffling and coughing Mitt, stares back at the shore with a fishing rod in his hand. Aaron Morton‘s camera shifts so that we are looking at Hewey, while just behind him, Mitt straps on a weight belt and steps off of the boat and into the sea. We cut then to Jay, waiting in the car at the cemetery for his mother, Zara (Elisabeth Shue), to return. Across the run time we will return to Mitt and Jay, uncovering more of their fraught relationship and absorbing some of the guilt which he feels for having lashed out at his father as he succumbed to his mesothelioma diagnosis and not opening his letter which Mitt had left each of his three children.
Pivoting back to Jay, the impetus for his early morning dive was from a heated conversation the night earlier in which he and his sisters, Eva (Jane Levy) and Nan (Emily Rudd), mourned the fact that they buried an empty coffin. With an hour’s worth of air on his back, Jay trapses into the surf determined to find his father’s remains. These underwater scenes are where the film ultimately excels with Morton’s camera taking us deep into the kelp forests and capturing the shallow fish swimming unbothered by Jay’s presence lending the sense that despite his protesting on land, he is very much at home under the waves. These more crystalline blues give way to the deeper and darker hues as Jay sits on the edge of the shelf, and from that darkness, a noise.
As Jay encroaches the deeper parts of the ocean, Morton hands over the title of creative high mark to composer Joseph Trapanese and Moksha Bruno, the executive of creative sound services. This team works to blend the terrifying, creaking sounds of pressure, the reverberating sonar of unseen beasts, and traditional, emotive cinematic scoring techniques to create a robust soundscape for a film that is about to transition from the wide-open ocean to the tight confines of a whale’s stomach chamber.
With this transition, the film also hands itself over fully to Abrams who is asked to act alongside himself, in an alien landscape that offers, likewise, little as a scene partner. It is here where Duffield’s and Kraus’ treatment of the material finds itself at it most formulaic; Jay gets into trouble, flashback, Jay remembers a lesson from his father to help him survive. Production designer Ramsey Avery leads his crafts crews to creating a squelchy and foreboding environment for Jay, one that gives slightly only to respond with a tenfold force setting our hero two steps back. There is still a sense of danger thanks to the squid and its severed beak that has one last clamp left in the tank. There is also the toxic air – sort of – and later some digestive juices, but much of Jay’s time spent inside of the whale is simply waiting as there are very few puzzles to solve inside of a whale’s stomach as opposed to the setting of just about any other escape thriller locale. Whalefall is not devoid of ingenuity as Jay does scrounge up some rudimentary tools to mount a near escape attempt late in the second act, but much like the bobbing of the ocean waves, the story’s rhythmic structure begins to lull us into a sleep.
Duffield and Kraus push the conceit of this film to its absolute limits, and when they steer into the third act, that our eyes are already a little heavy from the cyclical narrative helps place us in a not-so-dissimilar state of delirium that Jay is experiencing with mere minutes remaining in his air tank. Through the magic of cinema, those minutes last a good while, but Duffield and Kraus finally abandon the formula and deliver a surprisingly powerful rumination on loss, grief, and regret. “Outside” of the whale, Trapanese and Bruno create an otherworldly soundscape as a pod of orcas begin to attack the sperm whale that swallowed our hero. To escape, the whale quickly dives deeper into the sea and the pressure change wreaks havoc on what little sanity and composure Jay had left. In this new state of hopelessness, Mitt, through the whale, begins to speak to his frightened and resigned son and the film transforms into a beautiful poem on the fragility, and therefore, preciousness of life and how we can honor the legacy of those who have gone before us in order to keep them still alive in spirit though their body has passed. He explains the entire scientific and environmental phenomenon of a “whalefall” which is the term used to describe the ecosystem that forms around the sunken carcass of a deceased whale. It is on the nose, sure, but it helps tie the film up in a thematically resonant ribbon in a way that can be deeply appreciated by anyone who has experienced a loss in their life, which, given the – tightrope walking – PG-13 rating, is probably most of the audience.
Whalefall is a high concept film that held its well deployed sentimentality close to its chest for months ahead of its release, enduring the assault of memes and ribbing from film circles, suffering from being half written off before it ever reached an audience. Bowing in the prime horror corridor with traits of the genre and a surprising bit of brutal body horror and visceral injury, Whalefall lures its audience in with a to wild to be believed premise and the rising star power in Abrams, but reveals plenty to be enjoyed for a wide range of audiences. With that being said, that means there are plenty of points across the run time for the film to turn audiences away as it revels is aspects of the multifaceted plot that may not be of interest to them; too melodramatic, too gory, too downright weird. Like the mighty whale itself, Whalefall endures, and is one of the strangest and most sincere films of the year, and that is exists at all on the big screen points to a thriving theatrical environment and filmmaking class that are not afraid to still take some risks in storytelling, trusting that somewhere out there, its audience is waiting.